1.
Adrian Granados v Interlake, Inc 07 IWCC 600
Petitioner, 49
years old, injured his lumbar spine while working as a welder for
Respondent. Despite never having surgery,
all doctors
agreed that Petitioner was not be able to return back to work as a
welder due to physical restrictions. Respondent offered a different
job to Petitioner within his restrictions. However, after only working
the new job for only 2-3 hours, Petitioner went to an emergency room
claiming severe back pain. At hearing, Petitioner argued he was permanently
totally disabled under Section 8(e) of the Illinois Workers’ Compensation
Act due to the restrictions, his education (high school), and his claim
that he was not fluent in English with Spanish being his native language.
The arbitrator found that Petitioner was not permanently totally disabled
as Respondent had a bona fide job alternative for him. The Commission
on review agreed and further found that Petitioner did not attempt
to find alternate employment on his own. The Commission did increase
the award of permanency pursuant to Section 8(d)(2).
2.
Brenda J. Hill v Lincoln Land Oil Co (06IWCC1141)
Petitioner incurred a neck
injury while working as a gas station attendant. The arbitrator found
an intervening incident of lifting a heavy pot
while cooking at home which was mentioned to an emergency room physician
by a family member. Based on the intervening incident, the arbitrator
denied subsequent lost time benefits and medical expenses. The finding
of an intervening incident also mitigated the employer’s liability
for permanent partial disability benefits. Upon review, the Commission
affirmed the arbitrator’s decision.
3. Bing Gossett vs. ITW/Signode (01 IIC 12)
Petitioner alleged that
pre-existing arthritis in both hips and his right knee was aggravated
by his work as a machine operator. Petitioner
had bilateral total hip replacement and a total right knee replacement.
Petitioner asserted that he was permanently and totally disabled from
working as a machine operator due to the condition of his hips and
right knee. At the time of the alleged aggravation, petitioner was
52 years old. The Arbitrator found that petitioner failed to prove
that he suffered an injury which arose out of and in the course of
his employment. The Arbitrator relied on a 20 year history of prior
arthritic problems throughout his body, including fingers. The Arbitrator
also found that petitioner’s testimony in which he frequently
lifted 100 pound coils of steel was not credible. The Arbitrator denied
all forms of compensation. The Industrial Commission affirmed the Decision
on review.
4. Adellar Laye vs. Osco Drug (99 IIC 404)
Petitioner alleged an injury
to her lower back which occurred when she lifted and moved a number
of packages weighing between 12 to 60
pounds onto a pallet. Petitioner testified that she felt pain in her
lower back when she used a hand jack to lift the pallet off the floor.
Petitioner stated that she continued to work, moving the boxes off
the pallet at a different part of the store. Petitioner did not seek
medical treatment for the next 14 days. Petitioner testified that the
reason she did not seek treatment for that period of time was that
she was taking Tylenol #3 for a recent root canal and therefore did
not notice the pain in her lower back until after she stopped taking
the medication for her tooth. The Arbitrator found that petitioner
failed to prove that she sustained an injury which arose out of and
was in the course of her employment. The Arbitrator specifically noted
that the petitioner’s contention that her back pain was eliminated
entirely by the Tylenol #3 she was taking for her tooth was not supported
by competent evidence. The Arbitrator further found that any causal
connection between petitioner’s back pain and the accident was
speculation due to the fact that petitioner did not treat for her back
until two week after the alleged accident. The Arbitrator denied all
compensation for petitioner. The Industrial Commission affirmed the
Arbitrator’s Decision upon review.